Posted by Paul on August 9, 2009, 12:36 pm
Just dug up my broad beans after a very successful first year - never
knew my wife could be so inventive with broad bean recipes! (Favourite
probably bacon, mushroom & broad bean risotto)
My query is - can I (indeed should I) shell the last few pods for
drying to use as next year's starter seeds? Or am I best buying new
each year?
TIA for any advice
Paul
Posted by Pete C on August 9, 2009, 1:09 pm
Paul wrote:
> Just dug up my broad beans after a very successful first year - never
> knew my wife could be so inventive with broad bean recipes! (Favourite
> probably bacon, mushroom & broad bean risotto)
> My query is - can I (indeed should I) shell the last few pods for
> drying to use as next year's starter seeds? Or am I best buying new
> each year?
> TIA for any advice
> Paul
Yes, with a word of warning. When pollinating, bees etc may have visited a
different variety of bean, in which case you may not get a true variety. If
there are no other beans being grown closer than half a mile or so, it
should be ok. I'm doing the same with my runners, but only as a back up/out
of interest.
HTH :)
--
Pete C
London UK
Posted by shazzbat on August 9, 2009, 2:15 pm
> Paul wrote:
>> Just dug up my broad beans after a very successful first year - never
>> knew my wife could be so inventive with broad bean recipes! (Favourite
>> probably bacon, mushroom & broad bean risotto)
>>
>> My query is - can I (indeed should I) shell the last few pods for
>> drying to use as next year's starter seeds? Or am I best buying new
>> each year?
I know someone who has done this for 20+ years without problems. But if
you're wanting to grow some over winter, stick with one of the hardy
varieties such as aquadulce Claudia.
Steve
Posted by nmm1 on August 9, 2009, 2:57 pm
>> Paul wrote:
>>
>>> Just dug up my broad beans after a very successful first year - never
>>> knew my wife could be so inventive with broad bean recipes! (Favourite
>>> probably bacon, mushroom & broad bean risotto)
>>>
>>> My query is - can I (indeed should I) shell the last few pods for
>>> drying to use as next year's starter seeds? Or am I best buying new
>>> each year?
>I know someone who has done this for 20+ years without problems. But if
>you're wanting to grow some over winter, stick with one of the hardy
>varieties such as aquadulce Claudia.
It's fairly basic, but worth mentioning. Broad beans, as normally
used, are unripe and will not germinate - they can be dried and
used as dried beans without problems, of course. Any beans used
for seed MUST be left to ripen on the plant, and only picked after
the pod had gone leathery or even dry and hard.
Regards,
Nick Maclaren.
Posted by Pete C on August 9, 2009, 4:12 pm
nmm1@cam.ac.uk wrote:
>>> Paul wrote:
>>>
>>>> Just dug up my broad beans after a very successful first year -
>>>> never knew my wife could be so inventive with broad bean recipes!
>>>> (Favourite probably bacon, mushroom & broad bean risotto)
>>>>
>>>> My query is - can I (indeed should I) shell the last few pods for
>>>> drying to use as next year's starter seeds? Or am I best buying new
>>>> each year?
>>
>> I know someone who has done this for 20+ years without problems. But
>> if you're wanting to grow some over winter, stick with one of the
>> hardy varieties such as aquadulce Claudia.
> It's fairly basic, but worth mentioning. Broad beans, as normally
> used, are unripe and will not germinate - they can be dried and
> used as dried beans without problems, of course. Any beans used
> for seed MUST be left to ripen on the plant, and only picked after
> the pod had gone leathery or even dry and hard.
> Regards,
> Nick Maclaren.
Interesting.....thanks Nick :)
--
Pete C
London UK
> knew my wife could be so inventive with broad bean recipes! (Favourite
> probably bacon, mushroom & broad bean risotto)
> My query is - can I (indeed should I) shell the last few pods for
> drying to use as next year's starter seeds? Or am I best buying new
> each year?
> TIA for any advice
> Paul