Beans, danger of cross pollination?

 For the first time I'm growing broad beans. However I always grow runner
beans and collect some of the dried pods for the following years seeds.
Runner bean variety "Streamline" or at least that is what it said on the
original packet ten years ago! I've always found it a good strong
variety, pest resistant and the pods string-less. Could broad beans
cross pollinate with the runner beans and lead to hybrid bean seeds for
planting next year? I'm also assuming such crosses would not be desirable?

--
David in Normandy.   DavidinNormandy@yahoo.fr
   To e-mail you must include the password FROG on the
   subject line, or it will be automatically deleted
   by a filter and not reach my inbox.

 
'David in Normandy[_8_ Wrote:

Runner beans are Phaseolus coccineus and Broad beans are Vicia faba so
not even related so the chances of them crossing are rather remote.




--
Owdboggy

 
"Not even related" is a rather extreme conclusion from the plants being
in different genera. However they are not only in different genera, but
also in different tribes. Intertribal hybrids are even rarer than
intergeneric hybrids.

Broad beans turn out to be more closely related to peas than to runner
beans.
--
Stewart Robert Hinsley

 

David, I can only speak from my experience over the last 4? years.
I save seed from all beans and I have not noticed any X pollination at all.
Time will tell?
My broad bean "Aquadulce Claudia" already have small pods BTW, and "The
Sutton" are about ready to flower.
I only know of one chap who grows runner bean "Streamline" and I have some
seed from him, (they are rather old) and with what you have said about them
perhaps it's time I gave them a try. I have grown "Scarlet Emperor" since I
started gardening and have found them a bit stringy later on so maybe time
to try something new(to me). Or both.
I am sure that you have resarched growing broad beans, but it will do no
harm if I advise you to nip out the top of each plant when pods have set to
avoid greenfly, THE pest on broad beans from my experience.

I hope you find all this useful.
Baz

 On 06/04/2011 12:38, Baz wrote:

Thank you for the advice. I'm a total newbie to broad beans. I've just
planted some beans directly into the ground but have no idea how high
they will grow. According to the internet broad beans grow three to four
feet high so I've planted the beans between some pea sticks of that
height I've cut from my hazel trees. I don't know if they will be strong
enough. I always grow my runner beans up 8 foot bamboo canes all
fastened together in a long strong wigwam.

I've a few broad beans around 8 inches high in individual plant pots
that I germinated indoors and they've been outside the last few days
hardening off - I plan to try growing them around a bamboo wigwam. I am
assuming that broad beans twist themselves around supports the same as
runner beans?

Another very silly question - can broad beans be eaten as green beans ie
the pods and later on just the beans shelled from the pods themselves?
If eaten as beans (seeds) can they be allowed to fully ripen and be kept
dry overwinter for use in stews etc? The name of the variety is
something like Swiss white (Suisse blanc). The beans themselves are
white and approximately the size of the beans you get in baked bean
tins, not the huge beans I've seem other people with.

--
David in Normandy.   DavidinNormandy@yahoo.fr
   To e-mail you must include the password FROG on the
   subject line, or it will be automatically deleted
   by a filter and not reach my inbox.