Back issues of Gardens Illustrated - any good?

 
I have seen an auction for most back issues of gardens illustrated
here:-

'Gardens Illustrated Magazine most Back Issues, 1-168 on eBay (end time
25-Feb-11 11:32:29 GMT)' (http://tinyurl.com/4h9qupl )

I haven't really read them before, are they worth getting hold of as
they aren't too far away from me.




--
MankyManning

 wrote:


Definitely. A book is always better, from every point if view. Note
that the ad says "most back issues", so it isn't even complete: a
white elephant. Browse the gardening section of your library and see
what kind of thing you actually want; but if you're an absolute
beginner, then a good start would be the "Expert" books: have a look
at "The Garden Expert". It may tell you all you need, or simply be a
starter.

--
Mike.

 mike_lyle_uk@yahoo.co.uk says...

  I don't agree. The seller is offering 168 issues, no bids yet, so if
the price is right it could be a bargain; and an inspirational asset to
a beginner.
 In its early years especially, this was a very good and informative
gardening mag with beautiful illustrations.
IIRC a couple of urg's more famous and fabulous old contributors, wrote
for it. (Remember Tim, anyone?)

 Finding an article you want is no problem as GI have a free online
index at

http://www.gardensillustrated.com/magazine/index

  It offers a LOT of interesting but easily assimilated information
about gardening history, different styles, different areas of the UK,
local gardens etc; and a wealth of  stimulating ideas for making and
planting gardens.
Infinitely more interesting and inspiring than the Expert series, imo.

The OP can take a peek here, and use a mouse to leaf through the pages
of the current issue to
see if the style is of interest

http://www.gardensillustrated.com/issue/february-2011

   Janet.

 

Well, different strokes for different blokes. But ONE HUNDRED AND
SIXTY-EIGHT unbound issues of a magazine? (Say, about four feet of
pile or shelf? How much for postage?) And, if I understand correctly,
you have to go online to look in the index? And there are some
missing? I agree there are good articles and lovely pictures there,
but I still vote for a book or two.

--
Mike.

 On Wed, 23 Feb 2011 22:42:46 +0000, Mike Lyle


Sorry about the caps: I was thinking in italics, not shouting.

--
Mike.