Posted by Red on January 14, 2009, 10:16 am
I've got a flat 1 acre lot and am considering getting a smaller ztr
mower. I just compared the cub cadet and troy bilt 42" mowers and
found that they are made by the same company (MTD) and virtually
identical except for 1hp difference in the Kohler engine. Even most
parts are interchangeable. Well, maybe the cub cadet has a few minor
niceities. So my question is: is the cub cadets 1 extra hp (20 vs 19)
and a few minor features worth the $300 price difference or is it
paying for name recognition only?
Yeah, I know the Kawasaki engine is better but they only come on the
larger size mowers.
Red
Posted by Art on January 14, 2009, 8:01 pm
Red wrote:
> I've got a flat 1 acre lot and am considering getting a smaller ztr
> mower. I just compared the cub cadet and troy bilt 42" mowers and
> found that they are made by the same company (MTD) and virtually
> identical except for 1hp difference in the Kohler engine. Even most
> parts are interchangeable. Well, maybe the cub cadet has a few minor
> niceities. So my question is: is the cub cadets 1 extra hp (20 vs 19)
> and a few minor features worth the $300 price difference or is it
> paying for name recognition only?
> Yeah, I know the Kawasaki engine is better but they only come on the
> larger size mowers.
>
> Red
Both are pieces of crap. Don't throw away your money, buy a decent machine.
--
Art
Posted by KC on January 14, 2009, 8:44 pm
> Both are pieces of crap.
Why? Bear in mind the mower will be used on a single yard only and
not commercially.
> Don't throw away your money, buy a decent machine.
That's why I asked the question. Buying more mower than I need for
the job is throwing away money also. Is a Lexus better than a Chevy?
Yeah, but the Chevy will get me to Walmart and back just as many
times.
Red
Posted by Art on January 16, 2009, 8:59 pm
KC wrote:
>
>> Both are pieces of crap.
>
> Why? Bear in mind the mower will be used on a single yard only and
> not commercially.
>
MTD builds crap. I don't know why, you'd have to ask them. Parts are
thin stamped steel, bearings are poor quality, shafts are of minimal
diameter, blades are thin and not heat treated, tires from China. Every
part they use is absolutely the cheapest thing they can source.
There is also something to be said for the availability of things like a
mulcher, bagger or other towables or push attachments. MTD hasn't got
much and what they do have is usually ill-fitting and flimsy. Often
replacement parts for attachments are not available at all.
I suggest you take a look at a couple of homeowner models of Hustler,
Dixie Chopper, Snapper or whatever is available down at your local power
equipment store. There you can see the difference. Compare the weights
of the machine and the quality of the parts. Kick the tires even.
I realize you don't need a commercial machine but I'd think you'd want
the best bang for your buck and that is rarely found with the cheapest
product available. You may wind up with an MTD in the end but at least
you should know what else is out there.
--
Art
Posted by Red on January 17, 2009, 11:33 am
> KC wrote:
> >> Both are pieces of crap.
> > Why? Bear in mind the mower will be used on a single yard only and
> > not commercially.
> MTD builds crap. I don't know why, you'd have to ask them. Parts are
> thin stamped steel, bearings are poor quality, shafts are of minimal
> diameter, blades are thin and not heat treated, tires from China. Every
> part they use is absolutely the cheapest thing they can source.
> There is also something to be said for the availability of things like a
> mulcher, bagger or other towables or push attachments. MTD hasn't got
> much and what they do have is usually ill-fitting and flimsy. Often
> replacement parts for attachments are not available at all.
> I suggest you take a look at a couple of homeowner models of Hustler,
> Dixie Chopper, Snapper or whatever is available down at your local power
> equipment store. There you can see the difference. Compare the weights
> of the machine and the quality of the parts. Kick the tires even.
> I realize you don't need a commercial machine but I'd think you'd want
> the best bang for your buck and that is rarely found with the cheapest
> product available. You may wind up with an MTD in the end but at least
> you should know what else is out there.
> --
> Art
Thanks. Now that is a very informative reply. I will now be checking
out other models.
Red
> mower. I just compared the cub cadet and troy bilt 42" mowers and
> found that they are made by the same company (MTD) and virtually
> identical except for 1hp difference in the Kohler engine. Even most
> parts are interchangeable. Well, maybe the cub cadet has a few minor
> niceities. So my question is: is the cub cadets 1 extra hp (20 vs 19)
> and a few minor features worth the $300 price difference or is it
> paying for name recognition only?
> Yeah, I know the Kawasaki engine is better but they only come on the
> larger size mowers.
>
> Red