Posted by Cory Lechner on August 26, 2003, 11:29 am
We have a great deal of perennials throughout our property (Regina,
Saskatchewan).
1) Should we cut off the season's growth to the ground before winter comes?
2) Does the answer to #1 vary with species of perennial?
3) Does leaving the top on promote fungus growth?
Cory
Regina. Saskatchewan, Canada
Posted by Pam on August 26, 2003, 12:34 pm
Cory Lechner wrote:
> We have a great deal of perennials throughout our property (Regina,
> Saskatchewan).
> 1) Should we cut off the season's growth to the ground before winter comes?
> 2) Does the answer to #1 vary with species of perennial?
> 3) Does leaving the top on promote fungus growth?
> Cory
> Regina. Saskatchewan, Canada
There is really no right or wrong answer to this question - it depends on your
climate and preference. Many folks do a routine clean-up of their garden each
fall to ready it for winter that includes cutting back all herbaceous
perennials. Others leave selected plants as is over winter, either because they
offer late season attraction (sedum seedheads look great dusted with frost or
snow) or because they offer fodder to local wildlife. If you live in a hard
winter climate (I'm pretty sure Saskatchewan would qualify :-)), there is the
likelihood that leaving foliage intact over the winter will offer additional
winter protection to the root crown. This can lead to hiding places for
overwintering insects and diseases - depends on whether or not they are a big
problem in your area. You can always cut back and then mulch to get the same or
even superior winter protection.
pam - gardengal
Posted by Suja on August 26, 2003, 1:16 pm
Pam wrote:
> perennials. Others leave selected plants as is over winter, either because they
> offer late season attraction (sedum seedheads look great dusted with frost or
> snow) or because they offer fodder to local wildlife.
The other reason I wait till spring to do clean-up is because I don't
always remember where exactly I planted something, and especially if it
is late to come up in spring, might decide to plant something else in
that spot.
Suja
Posted by B & J on August 26, 2003, 11:32 pm
> Cory Lechner wrote:
> > We have a great deal of perennials throughout our property (Regina,
> > Saskatchewan).
> >
> > 1) Should we cut off the season's growth to the ground before winter
comes?
> >
> > 2) Does the answer to #1 vary with species of perennial?
> >
> > 3) Does leaving the top on promote fungus growth?
> >
> > Cory
> > Regina. Saskatchewan, Canada
> There is really no right or wrong answer to this question - it depends on
your
> climate and preference. Many folks do a routine clean-up of their garden
each
> fall to ready it for winter that includes cutting back all herbaceous
> perennials. Others leave selected plants as is over winter, either because
they
> offer late season attraction (sedum seedheads look great dusted with frost
or
> snow) or because they offer fodder to local wildlife. If you live in a
hard
> winter climate (I'm pretty sure Saskatchewan would qualify :-)), there is
the
> likelihood that leaving foliage intact over the winter will offer
additional
> winter protection to the root crown. This can lead to hiding places for
> overwintering insects and diseases - depends on whether or not they are a
big
> problem in your area. You can always cut back and then mulch to get the
same or
> even superior winter protection.
> pam - gardengal
Excellent advice - been there, done that. As an ammendment to your
suggestions, I found it usually paid to cut back and remove/destroy dead
plant material from perennials and replace its winter protection with red
pine or white pine needles (pine straw) in zone 3. It really cut down on
over-wintering diseases and bugs. I used plant stakes to identify where
perennials "should" sprout in the spring. They didn't always survive open
winters. :(
John
John
Posted by Peppergirl on August 26, 2003, 2:26 pm
Hi!
I always clean up my perennials in fall, depending on how they look,
especially if there are plants that tend to spread. In fact i'm thinking in
the next couple of weeks starting on mine.
Peppergirl
http://hotcuisine.esmartweb.com/
> We have a great deal of perennials throughout our property (Regina,
> Saskatchewan).
> 1) Should we cut off the season's growth to the ground before winter
comes?
> 2) Does the answer to #1 vary with species of perennial?
> 3) Does leaving the top on promote fungus growth?
> Cory
> Regina. Saskatchewan, Canada
> Saskatchewan).
> 1) Should we cut off the season's growth to the ground before winter comes?
> 2) Does the answer to #1 vary with species of perennial?
> 3) Does leaving the top on promote fungus growth?
> Cory
> Regina. Saskatchewan, Canada