Posted by hr(bob) hofmann@att.net on October 11, 2009, 6:30 pm
We have a 44 year old birch 3-trunk clump in our front yard that is
showing its age. Two of the 3 main trunks have vertical splits in
them that run from close to ground level up to 8 - 10 feet. The
leaves this year were full, but the splits in the trunks were deeper
than they were last year, and I fear that next year we may not see as
vigorous growth. We have been lucky and not had problems with birch
borers like many folks in the Chicago suburbs, at least as far as I
can tell. We spray annually for the borers as a precaution. I don't
know what caused the splits.
My wife is set on having birches or something that looks similar if we
have to replace the birch clump
If we have to replace the clump, I would like to plant something that
does not need annual spraying as we try to be as "green" as possible.
I don't think Aspens will grow well in the Chicago suburbs as I have
not seen any in any of the places we have looked at for replacement
trees. The big box stores treat their trees so poorly that I would
never buy from them unless I could buy the tree the same day it arived
at the store. We don;t have any nurseries close buiy to just go and
browse so I am hoping some folks here have some suggestions for
similarly looking trees..
Posted by David E. Ross on October 12, 2009, 12:33 am
On 10/11/2009 3:30 PM, hr(bob) hofmann@att.net wrote:
> We have a 44 year old birch 3-trunk clump in our front yard that is
> showing its age. Two of the 3 main trunks have vertical splits in
> them that run from close to ground level up to 8 - 10 feet. The
> leaves this year were full, but the splits in the trunks were deeper
> than they were last year, and I fear that next year we may not see as
> vigorous growth. We have been lucky and not had problems with birch
> borers like many folks in the Chicago suburbs, at least as far as I
> can tell. We spray annually for the borers as a precaution. I don't
> know what caused the splits.
>
> My wife is set on having birches or something that looks similar if we
> have to replace the birch clump
> If we have to replace the clump, I would like to plant something that
> does not need annual spraying as we try to be as "green" as possible.
> I don't think Aspens will grow well in the Chicago suburbs as I have
> not seen any in any of the places we have looked at for replacement
> trees. The big box stores treat their trees so poorly that I would
> never buy from them unless I could buy the tree the same day it arived
> at the store. We don;t have any nurseries close buiy to just go and
> browse so I am hoping some folks here have some suggestions for
> similarly looking trees..
Don't plant aspens or other species from the Populus genus (cottonwood,
poplar). They sucker badly from the roots, are shallow rooted, brittle,
clog sewer lines, and heave pavements. They are only good when planted
in groves on large tracts of land.
--
David E. Ross
Climate: California Mediterranean
Sunset Zone: 21 -- interior Santa Monica Mountains with some ocean
influence (USDA 10a, very close to Sunset Zone 19)
Gardening diary at <http://www.rossde.com/garden/diary>
XML site map
> showing its age. Two of the 3 main trunks have vertical splits in
> them that run from close to ground level up to 8 - 10 feet. The
> leaves this year were full, but the splits in the trunks were deeper
> than they were last year, and I fear that next year we may not see as
> vigorous growth. We have been lucky and not had problems with birch
> borers like many folks in the Chicago suburbs, at least as far as I
> can tell. We spray annually for the borers as a precaution. I don't
> know what caused the splits.
>
> My wife is set on having birches or something that looks similar if we
> have to replace the birch clump
> If we have to replace the clump, I would like to plant something that
> does not need annual spraying as we try to be as "green" as possible.
> I don't think Aspens will grow well in the Chicago suburbs as I have
> not seen any in any of the places we have looked at for replacement
> trees. The big box stores treat their trees so poorly that I would
> never buy from them unless I could buy the tree the same day it arived
> at the store. We don;t have any nurseries close buiy to just go and
> browse so I am hoping some folks here have some suggestions for
> similarly looking trees..