> wrote: > >> On 7/20/2011 8:20 PM, Paul M. Cook wrote: >>>> http://www.treehugger.com/files/2011/07/michigan_woman_faces_jail_planting >>>> _veggie_garden.php >>>> >>>> It just doesn't get more ridiculous than this. >>>> >>>> Julie Bass of Oak Park, Michigan -- a mother of 6, law-abiding citizen, >>>> and gardener -- is facing 93 days in jail after being charged with a >>>> misdemeanor. >>>> >>>> Her crime? Planting a vegetable garden in the front yard. >>> >>> >>> Nothing whatsoever liberal about this. Draconian punishments for trivial >>> offenses is a conservative policy. For all the bleeting about freedom, the >>> right would see all of us in a prison or at least very close to one. >> >> Charges were dropped. > > Good. I'd hardly call planting a vegetable garden "running amuck".
I am not sure, I believe one should obey the rules of the community in
which they live. If one lives in the suburbs I can see having rules against
owning horses or goats and ordinances for keeping a nice lawn. It can
devaluate the neighbors home. If one lives in a condominium, try even
having a tomato plant on the back patio without having the associations
approval. I can see where the majority wants a certain look and feel to a
community. If that person wants to do otherwise they should move somewhere
else.
In the country where I live there are no such ordinances. I do not even
have to mow my lawn and I can have old rusted out cars on my front lawn and
no one would say or do anything about it.
--
Enjoy Life... Nad R (Garden in zone 5a Michigan)
Posted by FarmI on July 21, 2011, 2:00 am
>> wrote: >> >>> On 7/20/2011 8:20 PM, Paul M. Cook wrote: >>>>> http://www.treehugger.com/files/2011/07/michigan_woman_faces_jail_planting >>>>> _veggie_garden.php >>>>> >>>>> It just doesn't get more ridiculous than this. >>>>> >>>>> Julie Bass of Oak Park, Michigan -- a mother of 6, law-abiding >>>>> citizen, >>>>> and gardener -- is facing 93 days in jail after being charged with a >>>>> misdemeanor. >>>>> >>>>> Her crime? Planting a vegetable garden in the front yard. >>>> >>>> >>>> Nothing whatsoever liberal about this. Draconian punishments for >>>> trivial >>>> offenses is a conservative policy. For all the bleeting about freedom, >>>> the >>>> right would see all of us in a prison or at least very close to one. >>> >>> Charges were dropped. >> >> Good. I'd hardly call planting a vegetable garden "running amuck". > I am not sure, I believe one should obey the rules of the community in > which they live. If one lives in the suburbs I can see having rules > against > owning horses or goats and ordinances for keeping a nice lawn.
There are very valid health reasons for having rules against keeping horses
or pigs or poultry, but having rules for keeping "a nice lawn"? That is
simply about control and restriction of choice.
It can
> devaluate the neighbors home.
I'd pay more for a place with a decent dry garden rather than a 'nice lawn'.
If one lives in a condominium, try even
> having a tomato plant on the back patio without having the associations > approval. I can see where the majority wants a certain look and feel to a > community. If that person wants to do otherwise they should move somewhere > else.
That is one building so TMWOT it's a bit of a stretch to call it a
'community'. It's hardly community minded to whine or have rules about a
person having one tomato plant on their deck.
> In the country where I live there are no such ordinances. I do not even > have to mow my lawn and I can have old rusted out cars on my front lawn > and > no one would say or do anything about it.
Well that soudns much better than living some place where anal retentives
waffle on about 'nice lawns'.
Posted by Nad R on July 21, 2011, 4:19 am
> That is one building so TMWOT it's a bit of a stretch to call it a > 'community'. It's hardly community minded to whine or have rules about a > person having one tomato plant on their deck.
Do not bet on that one... It depends on the association. Some condominiums
have very strict rules. Such places are nice for the elderly and those with
a busy city lifestyle.
>> In the country where I live there are no such ordinances. I do not even >> have to mow my lawn and I can have old rusted out cars on my front lawn >> and >> no one would say or do anything about it. > > Well that soudns much better than living some place where anal retentives > waffle on about 'nice lawns'.
The US has different kinds of communities and I believe those that are like
minded should have them. There are communities in which cars are not
allowed, like Mackinaw Island in Michigan. There are communities where
people have airplanes and small jets with small hangers instead of garages
next to there homes with a shared runway. Boating communities. Communities
with golf courses. Communities where there are elderly only no kids... Each
community with their own flavor, some with grass lawns only. Choose your
home, choose your lifestyle. I choose the country where there are few
restrictions.
When I was a kid. I use to ride my bicycle through Oak Park Michigan to get
the Americana Theater. Nice city forty years ago. Today If you ride your
bike there... Pedal Fast if you want to keep your bike.
--
Enjoy Life... Nad R (Garden in zone 5a Michigan)
Posted by Billy on July 21, 2011, 1:03 pm
> > > That is one building so TMWOT it's a bit of a stretch to call it a > > 'community'. It's hardly community minded to whine or have rules about a > > person having one tomato plant on their deck. > > Do not bet on that one... It depends on the association. Some condominiums > have very strict rules. Such places are nice for the elderly and those with > a busy city lifestyle.
Bad laws make bad citizens. How does growing a tomato reduce the quality
of life for the elderly, or those with a "busy city life style"
(whatever that is)?
> > >> In the country where I live there are no such ordinances. I do not even > >> have to mow my lawn and I can have old rusted out cars on my front lawn > >> and > >> no one would say or do anything about it.
So, freedom only belongs to the landed (wealthy)? This may square with
the reality of American history, but certainly not its ideals.
Shelly has often flaunted the surface area he controls, in the vain
attempt to bask in the envy that it might elicit, but at the end of the
day, he is still just Shelly.
> > > > Well that soudns much better than living some place where anal retentives > > waffle on about 'nice lawns'. > > The US has different kinds of communities and I believe those that are like > minded should have them. There are communities in which cars are not > allowed, like Mackinaw Island in Michigan. There are communities where > people have airplanes and small jets with small hangers instead of garages > next to there homes with a shared runway. Boating communities. Communities > with golf courses.
The above refer to zoning laws.
> Communities where there are elderly only no kids... Each > community with their own flavor, some with grass lawns only. Choose your > home, choose your lifestyle.
Some have accused homeowners associations of selective enforcement of
these rules, making a case only when it is something (or someone)
another person dislikes. Breaking a rule, even unintentionally, can
bring fines or even a lien on the home. In extreme cases, a homeowners'
association may file a lawsuit against an owner who violates the
covenants or even foreclose the property.
Restrictive covenants have evolved with some being found to be illegal,
i.e. Shelley v. Kraemer. Restrictive covenants that bar the growing of
food, that don't involve health risks, make no sense (or worse) in
today's world, where a handful of corporations control what we eat.
> I choose the country where there are few > restrictions.
With more money comes more choices with fewer restrictions (and more
freedom), a plutocracy, if you will, which is indicative of our "Zeit
Geist".
> > When I was a kid. I use to ride my bicycle through Oak Park Michigan to get > the Americana Theater. Nice city forty years ago. Today If you ride your > bike there... Pedal Fast if you want to keep your bike.
Where does this come from, and how does it fit into the discussion?
Crime changes with time. When there was a large middle class, middle
class ethics motivated people. As the middle class disappears, we are
left with the ethics of the upper and lower classes who know you only
get what you can take.
--
- Billy
America is not broke. The country is awash in wealth and cash.
It's just that it's not in your hands. It has been transferred, in the
greatest heist in history, from the workers and consumers to the banks
and the portfolios of the uber-rich.
<http://www.politifact.com/wisconsin/statements/2011/mar/10/michael-moore
/michael-moore-says-400-americans-have-more-wealth-/>
You put Lloyd Blankfein in pound-me-in-the-ass prison for one six-month term,
and all this bullshit would stop, all over Wall Street. That's all it would
take. Just once.
Posted by Billy on July 21, 2011, 3:27 pm
In article
> > > > > > That is one building so TMWOT it's a bit of a stretch to call it a > > > 'community'. It's hardly community minded to whine or have rules about > > > a > > > person having one tomato plant on their deck. > > > > Do not bet on that one... It depends on the association. Some condominiums > > have very strict rules. Such places are nice for the elderly and those with > > a busy city lifestyle. > Bad laws make bad citizens. How does growing a tomato reduce the quality > of life for the elderly, or those with a "busy city life style" > (whatever that is)? > > > > >> In the country where I live there are no such ordinances. I do not even > > >> have to mow my lawn and I can have old rusted out cars on my front lawn > > >> and > > >> no one would say or do anything about it. > So, freedom only belongs to the landed (wealthy)? This may square with > the reality of American history, but certainly not its ideals. > > Shelly has often flaunted the surface area he controls, in the vain > attempt to bask in the envy that it might elicit, but at the end of the > day, he is still just Shelly. > > > > > > Well that soudns much better than living some place where anal retentives > > > waffle on about 'nice lawns'. > > > > The US has different kinds of communities and I believe those that are like > > minded should have them. There are communities in which cars are not > > allowed, like Mackinaw Island in Michigan. There are communities where > > people have airplanes and small jets with small hangers instead of garages > > next to there homes with a shared runway. Boating communities. Communities > > with golf courses. > > The above refer to zoning laws. > > > Communities where there are elderly only no kids... Each > > community with their own flavor, some with grass lawns only. Choose your > > home, choose your lifestyle. > > Some have accused homeowners associations of selective enforcement of > these rules, making a case only when it is something (or someone) > another person dislikes. Breaking a rule, even unintentionally, can > bring fines or even a lien on the home. In extreme cases, a homeowners' > association may file a lawsuit against an owner who violates the > covenants or even foreclose the property. > > Restrictive covenants have evolved with some being found to be illegal, > i.e. Shelley v. Kraemer. Restrictive covenants that bar the growing of > food, that don't involve health risks, make no sense (or worse) in > today's world, where a handful of corporations control what we eat. > > > I choose the country where there are few > > restrictions. > > With more money comes more choices with fewer restrictions (and more > freedom), a plutocracy, if you will, which is indicative of our "Zeit > Geist". > > > > When I was a kid. I use to ride my bicycle through Oak Park Michigan to get > > the Americana Theater. Nice city forty years ago. Today If you ride your > > bike there... Pedal Fast if you want to keep your bike. > > Where does this come from, and how does it fit into the discussion? > Crime changes with time. When there was a large middle class, middle > class ethics motivated people. As the middle class disappears, we are > left with the ethics of the upper and lower classes who know you only > get what you can take.
<
--
- Billy
Obama is now backing a bipartisan Senate budget plan that would overhaul Social
Security and Medicare, while cutting taxes on the wealthy.
<http://www.democracynow.org/2011/7/21/headlines>
<
<
<
Vote 3rd Party
>
>> On 7/20/2011 8:20 PM, Paul M. Cook wrote:
>>>> http://www.treehugger.com/files/2011/07/michigan_woman_faces_jail_planting
>>>> _veggie_garden.php
>>>>
>>>> It just doesn't get more ridiculous than this.
>>>>
>>>> Julie Bass of Oak Park, Michigan -- a mother of 6, law-abiding citizen,
>>>> and gardener -- is facing 93 days in jail after being charged with a
>>>> misdemeanor.
>>>>
>>>> Her crime? Planting a vegetable garden in the front yard.
>>>
>>>
>>> Nothing whatsoever liberal about this. Draconian punishments for trivial
>>> offenses is a conservative policy. For all the bleeting about freedom, the
>>> right would see all of us in a prison or at least very close to one.
>>
>> Charges were dropped.
>
> Good. I'd hardly call planting a vegetable garden "running amuck".