Posted by Chris Thompson on August 1, 2011, 3:42 pm
Hi all
I just inherited a rectangular planter, about 3 feet by 16 inches by 16
inches deep. I am looking for suggestions on what to stick in there. I live
in Rockaway, NYC, close to the ocean, so salt might be an issue. We do get
hard freezes here. I would prefer some kind of hardy perennial. Would some
lilacs do OK in that size planter? I don't know if they could take the
winters. Thanks
Chris
Posted by Brooklyn1 on August 1, 2011, 5:40 pm
On Mon, 01 Aug 2011 14:42:15 -0500, Chris Thompson
>Hi all
>I just inherited a rectangular planter, about 3 feet by 16 inches by 16
>inches deep. I am looking for suggestions on what to stick in there. I live
>in Rockaway, NYC, close to the ocean, so salt might be an issue. We do get
>hard freezes here. I would prefer some kind of hardy perennial. Would some
>lilacs do OK in that size planter? I don't know if they could take the
>winters.
Lilac likes winter but doesn't like planters. Many succulents do
well.
Posted by David E. Ross on August 1, 2011, 8:51 pm
On 8/1/11 12:42 PM, Chris Thompson wrote:
> Hi all
>
> I just inherited a rectangular planter, about 3 feet by 16 inches by 16
> inches deep. I am looking for suggestions on what to stick in there. I live
> in Rockaway, NYC, close to the ocean, so salt might be an issue. We do get
> hard freezes here. I would prefer some kind of hardy perennial. Would some
> lilacs do OK in that size planter? I don't know if they could take the
> winters. Thanks
>
> Chris
Lilacs enjoy a cold winter. My daughter lives in Saskatoon, Canada,
where winter temperatures below -30F are common and lilacs are so common
that they are a cliche.
Salt should not be an issue if the potting mix in the container drains
well. You might want to add a little gypsum once a year to help remove
salt from the soil, but salt in the air should not be a major problem.
However, lilacs are woody shrubs that can grow quite large. I don't
think your container is deep enough.
The best source of a recommendation might be a nearby comprehensive
nursery (not a hardware store or lumber yard).
--
David E. Ross
Climate: California Mediterranean, see
<http://www.rossde.com/garden/climate.html>
Gardening diary at <http://www.rossde.com/garden/diary>
Posted by Chris Thompson on August 1, 2011, 9:06 pm
> On 8/1/11 12:42 PM, Chris Thompson wrote:
>> Hi all
>>
>> I just inherited a rectangular planter, about 3 feet by 16 inches by
>> 16 inches deep. I am looking for suggestions on what to stick in
>> there. I live in Rockaway, NYC, close to the ocean, so salt might be
>> an issue. We do get hard freezes here. I would prefer some kind of
>> hardy perennial. Would some lilacs do OK in that size planter? I
>> don't know if they could take the winters. Thanks
>>
>> Chris
>
> Lilacs enjoy a cold winter. My daughter lives in Saskatoon, Canada,
> where winter temperatures below -30F are common and lilacs are so
> common that they are a cliche.
>
> Salt should not be an issue if the potting mix in the container drains
> well. You might want to add a little gypsum once a year to help
> remove salt from the soil, but salt in the air should not be a major
> problem.
>
> However, lilacs are woody shrubs that can grow quite large. I don't
> think your container is deep enough.
>
> The best source of a recommendation might be a nearby comprehensive
> nursery (not a hardware store or lumber yard).
>
Do you think one of the "dwarf" varieties might do well, if I kept it well-
pruned?
Thanks
Chris
Posted by despen on August 1, 2011, 10:17 pm
>> On 8/1/11 12:42 PM, Chris Thompson wrote:
>>> Hi all
>>>
>>> I just inherited a rectangular planter, about 3 feet by 16 inches by
>>> 16 inches deep. I am looking for suggestions on what to stick in
>>> there. I live in Rockaway, NYC, close to the ocean, so salt might be
>>> an issue. We do get hard freezes here. I would prefer some kind of
>>> hardy perennial. Would some lilacs do OK in that size planter? I
>>> don't know if they could take the winters. Thanks
>>>
>>> Chris
>>
>> Lilacs enjoy a cold winter. My daughter lives in Saskatoon, Canada,
>> where winter temperatures below -30F are common and lilacs are so
>> common that they are a cliche.
>>
>> Salt should not be an issue if the potting mix in the container drains
>> well. You might want to add a little gypsum once a year to help
>> remove salt from the soil, but salt in the air should not be a major
>> problem.
>>
>> However, lilacs are woody shrubs that can grow quite large. I don't
>> think your container is deep enough.
>>
>> The best source of a recommendation might be a nearby comprehensive
>> nursery (not a hardware store or lumber yard).
> Do you think one of the "dwarf" varieties might do well, if I kept it well-
> pruned?
Lilacs bloom in early spring and are relatively unattractive the rest of
the year.
Dwarf lilacs are 4 to 8 feet tall.
I have 2 outside a window that I appreciate in spring but once I start
spending time outside, they're done.
I'd be inclined to fill a planter with annuals.
--
Dan Espen
>I just inherited a rectangular planter, about 3 feet by 16 inches by 16
>inches deep. I am looking for suggestions on what to stick in there. I live
>in Rockaway, NYC, close to the ocean, so salt might be an issue. We do get
>hard freezes here. I would prefer some kind of hardy perennial. Would some
>lilacs do OK in that size planter? I don't know if they could take the
>winters.