Posted by James on April 24, 2010, 10:50 am
I am a very new rose grower (I hope). I have read that Miracle Gro
plant food (the kind you mix in water), and fish emulsion are good basics.
Can I mix the two in one gallon of water , for one application ?
Are there better feeding products ? Is the water soluable Miracle Gro
better than a pelletized fertilizer (which I know would last longer, but
not as fast acting, right ?)
Thanks for any **basic** fertilizing tips !!
James
Posted by Tony on April 24, 2010, 11:04 am
James wrote:
> I am a very new rose grower (I hope). I have read that Miracle Gro
> plant food (the kind you mix in water), and fish emulsion are good basics.
>
> Can I mix the two in one gallon of water , for one application ?
>
> Are there better feeding products ? Is the water soluable Miracle Gro
> better than a pelletized fertilizer (which I know would last longer, but
> not as fast acting, right ?)
>
> Thanks for any **basic** fertilizing tips !!
>
> James
>
I suppose you could mix them together, but I can't see why you'd want to
- MG and fish emulsion simultaneously is a awful lot of nitrogen at
once. Actually, if you want to use the liquid MG, use it every other
time you feed, in alternation with the fish emulsion. The fish emulsion
has many other soil benefits that the MG doesn't.
Tony
Posted by James on April 24, 2010, 11:43 am
Thanks Tony !!
Do you think the MG is equally good , compared to a pellitized fertilizer ?
As you suggest, I will apply MG and fish emulsion as alternate feedings.
James
Posted by Tony on April 24, 2010, 12:40 pm
James wrote:
> Thanks Tony !!
>
> Do you think the MG is equally good , compared to a pellitized fertilizer ?
>
> As you suggest, I will apply MG and fish emulsion as alternate feedings.
>
> James
>
In my opinion (and you will get others, believe me), the question should
be "Which pelletized fertilizer, and for what plant?" You say you are a
rose grower (I've never grown roses). I prefer to garden as organically
as possible, but I am not 100% organic. I'm guessing there is a good
pelletized completely natural rose fertilizer, or perhaps several of
them, out there, if you want to go that route. Talk to a nurseryman
(not the 17-year-old kid working in Home Depot's garden center). Decide
for yourself what you want to use.
IME, Miracle Grow is most useful diluted to 1/2 strength as a transplant
solution (it's great for that), and for things that benefit from an
occasional foliar feeding. A solid fertilizer properly mixed into the
soil may feed more uniformly over a longer period of time.
And before you follow ANY of the above advice, go to Google, type in
"growing roses", and you'll turn enough articles to keep you busy for
several evenings. As you go from source to source, you'll begin to see
patterns emerge: Basic points all the authors seem to agree on (note
those well!) and other, seemingly more contradictory advice (get back to
that later).
Tony
Posted by brooklyn1 on April 24, 2010, 1:24 pm
James wrote:
>
> Do you think the MG is equally good , compared to a pellitized fertilizer ?
>
> As you suggest, I will apply MG and fish emulsion as alternate feedings.
http://www.growingroses.org/
> plant food (the kind you mix in water), and fish emulsion are good basics.
>
> Can I mix the two in one gallon of water , for one application ?
>
> Are there better feeding products ? Is the water soluable Miracle Gro
> better than a pelletized fertilizer (which I know would last longer, but
> not as fast acting, right ?)
>
> Thanks for any **basic** fertilizing tips !!
>
> James
>