> > > is off topic. > > > > For Pete's sake will you shove your off topic posts up your left nostril > > and > > set them alight! > > > > I've already seem one other ng absolutely killed by off topic posts which > > turned the group from being a generalised discussion group for posters from > > aroudn the world to one about US politics and solely US politics. Either > > post about garden related topics of STFU. > > IWNSTFU Kill file me.
I have yet seen a newsgroup that doesn't go Off Topic, or contend with
trolls or spammers. Sometimes in our exuberance we become excessive, but
it is because of things about which we feel passionately (not to say
that I wouldn't KF Dr. Chung, if he shows up here). Both of you, FarmI
and Emily, are highly respected in this group, and your pronouncements
not lightly taken by myself. I'm sorry, if my continuing rage against
our government, and its murderous policies disturbs you. On the other
hand, we are individuals, each off whom plays our own little parts in
celebrating and furthering gardening. All in all, I think that the good
that we do, outweighs the bad.
Thank you for the criticism, because I know you want to be part of
something better. We all do.
--
- Billy
"Fascism should more properly be called corporatism because it is the
merger of state and corporate power." - Benito Mussolini.
> I have yet seen a newsgroup that doesn't go Off Topic,
Going 'off topic' as a result of thread drift is one thing but deliberately
posting something that is totally OT is quite another. It is not even as if
any attempt was made to disguise the topic such as writing about perhaps
shooting something in the garden and then weaving in comments that apply
only to arcane US political speak.
or contend with
> trolls or spammers. Sometimes in our exuberance we become excessive, but > it is because of things about which we feel passionately (not to say > that I wouldn't KF Dr. Chung, if he shows up here). Both of you, FarmI > and Emily, are highly respected in this group, and your pronouncements > not lightly taken by myself. I'm sorry, if my continuing rage against > our government, and its murderous policies disturbs you.
Don't you think that in an ng where the topic is gardening, that those of us
who come here to read about gardening might be allowed to have a bit of
freedom from American politics? Many posters here don't live in the US so
it's OTT at the very least to foist such posting on us.
On the other
> hand, we are individuals, each off whom plays our own little parts in > celebrating and furthering gardening. All in all, I think that the good > that we do, outweighs the bad. > Thank you for the criticism, because I know you want to be part of > something better. We all do.
Which is why I garden. If I want to talk about politics or guns or other
non gardening related issues, I do those in forums where that is the norm.
Posted by Steve B on April 25, 2010, 10:07 am
>> I have yet seen a newsgroup that doesn't go Off Topic, > Going 'off topic' as a result of thread drift is one thing but > deliberately posting something that is totally OT is quite another. It is > not even as if any attempt was made to disguise the topic such as writing > about perhaps shooting something in the garden and then weaving in > comments that apply only to arcane US political speak. > or contend with >> trolls or spammers. Sometimes in our exuberance we become excessive, but >> it is because of things about which we feel passionately (not to say >> that I wouldn't KF Dr. Chung, if he shows up here). Both of you, FarmI >> and Emily, are highly respected in this group, and your pronouncements >> not lightly taken by myself. I'm sorry, if my continuing rage against >> our government, and its murderous policies disturbs you. > Don't you think that in an ng where the topic is gardening, that those of > us who come here to read about gardening might be allowed to have a bit of > freedom from American politics? Many posters here don't live in the US so > it's OTT at the very least to foist such posting on us. > On the other >> hand, we are individuals, each off whom plays our own little parts in >> celebrating and furthering gardening. All in all, I think that the good >> that we do, outweighs the bad. >> >> Thank you for the criticism, because I know you want to be part of >> something better. We all do. > Which is why I garden. If I want to talk about politics or guns or other > non gardening related issues, I do those in forums where that is the norm.
I usually just read the subject. If it says, say, "How to seduce a sheep",
I don't even click into it, because I have an idea what it is about, I'm no
longer interested in the subject, and don't want to read it. If I click
into a message that is titled Onion cultivation, and see that the thread
drift has taken it into a discussion about the big O, I treat it the same
way, or mark the thread, knowing it has been discussed out.
But that's just me. Some people like to bark about how Usenet should be in
a perfect world. I just adjust to the one I have.
Steve
Posted by Bill who putters on April 25, 2010, 10:26 am
> > > >> I have yet seen a newsgroup that doesn't go Off Topic, > > > > Going 'off topic' as a result of thread drift is one thing but > > deliberately posting something that is totally OT is quite another. It is > > not even as if any attempt was made to disguise the topic such as writing > > about perhaps shooting something in the garden and then weaving in > > comments that apply only to arcane US political speak. > > > > or contend with > >> trolls or spammers. Sometimes in our exuberance we become excessive, but > >> it is because of things about which we feel passionately (not to say > >> that I wouldn't KF Dr. Chung, if he shows up here). Both of you, FarmI > >> and Emily, are highly respected in this group, and your pronouncements > >> not lightly taken by myself. I'm sorry, if my continuing rage against > >> our government, and its murderous policies disturbs you. > > > > Don't you think that in an ng where the topic is gardening, that those of > > us who come here to read about gardening might be allowed to have a bit of > > freedom from American politics? Many posters here don't live in the US so > > it's OTT at the very least to foist such posting on us. > > > > On the other > >> hand, we are individuals, each off whom plays our own little parts in > >> celebrating and furthering gardening. All in all, I think that the good > >> that we do, outweighs the bad. > >> > >> Thank you for the criticism, because I know you want to be part of > >> something better. We all do. > > > > Which is why I garden. If I want to talk about politics or guns or other > > non gardening related issues, I do those in forums where that is the norm. > > I usually just read the subject. If it says, say, "How to seduce a sheep", > I don't even click into it, because I have an idea what it is about, I'm no > longer interested in the subject, and don't want to read it. If I click > into a message that is titled Onion cultivation, and see that the thread > drift has taken it into a discussion about the big O, I treat it the same > way, or mark the thread, knowing it has been discussed out. > > But that's just me. Some people like to bark about how Usenet should be in > a perfect world. I just adjust to the one I have. > > Steve
Yes and people that know about cabg don't worry about the small
things. Guess I should have wrote cabbage.
--
Bill Garden in shade zone 5 S Jersey USA
Posted by R M Watkin on April 25, 2010, 3:23 pm
Hi All,
>> >>> I have yet seen a newsgroup that doesn't go Off Topic, >> >> Going 'off topic' as a result of thread drift is one thing but >> deliberately posting something that is totally OT is quite another. It >> is not even as if any attempt was made to disguise the topic such as >> writing about perhaps shooting something in the garden and then weaving >> in comments that apply only to arcane US political speak. >> >> or contend with >>> trolls or spammers. Sometimes in our exuberance we become excessive, but >>> it is because of things about which we feel passionately (not to say >>> that I wouldn't KF Dr. Chung, if he shows up here). Both of you, FarmI >>> and Emily, are highly respected in this group, and your pronouncements >>> not lightly taken by myself. I'm sorry, if my continuing rage against >>> our government, and its murderous policies disturbs you. >> >> Don't you think that in an ng where the topic is gardening, that those of >> us who come here to read about gardening might be allowed to have a bit >> of freedom from American politics? Many posters here don't live in the >> US so it's OTT at the very least to foist such posting on us. >> >> On the other >>> hand, we are individuals, each off whom plays our own little parts in >>> celebrating and furthering gardening. All in all, I think that the good >>> that we do, outweighs the bad. >>> >>> Thank you for the criticism, because I know you want to be part of >>> something better. We all do. >> >> Which is why I garden. If I want to talk about politics or guns or other >> non gardening related issues, I do those in forums where that is the >> norm. > I usually just read the subject. If it says, say, "How to seduce a > sheep", I don't even click into it, because I have an idea what it is > about, I'm no longer interested in the subject, and don't want to read it. > If I click into a message that is titled Onion cultivation, and see that > the thread drift has taken it into a discussion about the big O, I treat > it the same way, or mark the thread, knowing it has been discussed out. > But that's just me. Some people like to bark about how Usenet should be > in a perfect world. I just adjust to the one I have. > Steve
I do not live in the U.S. I still read all the O. T. stuff as I find it
interesting,
and it sretches the mind to see how other people live.
> > is off topic.
> >
> > For Pete's sake will you shove your off topic posts up your left nostril
> > and
> > set them alight!
> >
> > I've already seem one other ng absolutely killed by off topic posts which
> > turned the group from being a generalised discussion group for posters from
> > aroudn the world to one about US politics and solely US politics. Either
> > post about garden related topics of STFU.
>
> IWNSTFU Kill file me.